Working with editors and reviewers
A review runs smoothly when everyone knows their part. Editors turn feedback into fixes; reviewers give clear notes and confirm the fixes. Magpiie keeps both sides in sync without drowning anyone in pings.
Who does what
| Editors (including writers, designers, audio engineers) | Reviewers (producers, creators, clients) |
|---|---|
| Upload drafts and new versions, with release notes. | Leave pinned comments with a category and priority. |
| Work through assigned comments and update their state. | Answer questions on comments marked Needs info. |
| Reply when a note is unclear or cannot be done. | Check fixes on the new version and reopen what did not land. |
| Resolve comments once the fix is in. | Approve the version when it is ready. |
Notifications
- Editors are notified as soon as feedback arrives.
- Reviewers are notified when a new revision is ready for them.
- Anyone can switch to a daily digest instead of constant pings.
- Gentle reminders surface reviews that are still pending.
- Each person sets their own notification preferences.
A healthy review rhythm
- The editor uploads a version with release notes saying what to look at.
- Reviewers leave all their notes in one pass, by an agreed time.
- The editor asks questions in the threads, then works through the comments.
- The next version goes up, and reviewers check the carried-forward notes.
- Repeat until the draft is approval-ready, then approve.